mercredi 18 novembre 2026

No Pyramids Before the Flood


Ark Encounter
18.XI.2026
The Bible describes people before the Flood crafting musical instruments and forging tools of bronze and iron (Genesis 4:22).

I

Ark Encounter
https://arkencounter.com/noah/days-of-noah/

II

HGL
This doesn't put archaeology's Bronze and Iron ages before the Flood, though.

The latter ones are post-Flood rediscoveries.

III

MB
Funny how the Egyptians managed to complete the pyramids with all the flooding going on around them. Must have been a union job.

OC
MB the pyramids were built after the flood.

MB
OC flood supposedly happened around 2348 BCE. The first pyramid was built around 2630 BCE.

Google is free my dude

MD
OC The chinese cemeteries documented as dating back over 13,000 years also after the flood? Also, the native Americans that were around 15,000 years ago also missed the memo.

BC
OC Around 2350 BCE—the date traditional biblical chronologies assign to the Noachian flood—Egyptian civilization was thriving in the late Old Kingdom, specifically during the Fifth and Sixth Dynasties. Rather than experiencing a global catastrophe, Egypt was a highly organized, literate, and centralized state with an explosion of written records that had no mention of such a global (or even local) catastrophe...

PO
OC the pyramids were built when the total world population would have only been a few hundred at most?

KJ
MB
Not if you use the Greek LXX, 3298 BC.

KJ
MD
Chinese cemetary ages are based on C-14.

Contamination, reservoir effects (especially in freshwater or cave systems), and the absence of suitable materials can affect results.

So, you don't know how old they really are.

CJ
MB And we know Egyptian kings lists were never inflated timelines because?

WP
Super fan
MB Google does not know when they were built

MB
WP historical records, archeological context and radiocarbon dating... puts the oldest as being built around 200-300 years before the flood

HGL
KJ 2958 BC is quite OK.

HGL
KJ I actually do know how old the Chinese tomb dated to 13 000 BP = 11 050 BC.

Between 2647 BC (dated 11,618 BC) and 2634 BC (dated 10,851 BC).

The American from 15,000 BP or 13,050 BC is between 2699 BC (dated 15,666 BC) and 2686 BC (dated 14,456 BC), or around 2691 BC, when Eber was born.

As said, this is within centuries after the Flood in 2958 BC.

HGL
MB "The first pyramid was built around 2630 BCE."

Isn't the raw carbon date sth like 2800 BC?

Because that would be when Joseph was in Egypt, around 1700 BC.

HGL
BC "with an explosion of written records"

None of which establish a strict Egyptian chronology.

HGL
PO Flood in 2958. Pyramid in 1700, BC both times.

Babel was built starting 350 after the Flood (Noah's death) and ending 401 after the Flood (Peleg's birth).

It's called Göbekli Tepe. 2608 to 2557 BC.

AND, starting with 8 people, taking 3 % annual population growth, there were 248 954 back at Babel. Now, what if it had kept up to 1700 BC?

It would already have been 112,802,484,737,046,064 people, so the population growth must have slowed down after Babel.

HGL
CJ Because we absolutely don't know it.

They had no epoch, every year was year n after the reign of the current monarch, no single chronology counting years across them, you could add as many years to a previous monarch (or take them away) as you liked.

PO
HGL The major Egyptian pyramids were built during the Old Kingdom period, roughly between 2630 BC and 2500 BC.
Göbeklitepe is a Pre-Pottery Neolithic archaeological site in southeastern Turkey dating back to roughly 9600–8200 BCE,
Simple geometric population growth doesn't even begin to apply when there are only 8 people.

Everything you said is wrong.

HGL
PO You have taken the carbon dates at face value, supported by nothing better than King lists.

When there are only 8 people and so no competition for resources, the initial population growth is far beyond 3 % annually.

If there is any of your points you find I didn't adress this way, show me what.

GM
OC How long after?

KJ
HGL
C-14 dating. To me, not reliable.

I know two men who have worked in C-14 labs who both told me that calibration is a joke.

C-14 has been found inside diamonds and not just by YEC.

The measured 14C is intrinsic (or largely so), that diamonds’ hardness and crystal structure make contamination unlikely, and that the presence of detectable radiocarbon is therefore incompatible with multi-million- or billion-year ages. Some discussions within that framework also invoke possible secondary production (e.g., neutron capture) or accelerated nuclear decay in the past.

PO
HGL carbon dating has been thoroughly tested and verified. Creationist attempts to refute it consistently prove to be complete BS.

https://youtu.be/APEpwkXatbY?is=feXGdZvLQayqjluZ

The King's list and other archaeological records.

Meanwhile, you provided Jack squat supporting your dates.

After the flood, there wouldn't be any resources. Land plants can't survive being underwater. The animal population was reduced to a single pair each. Takes a year for most domesticated species to reach adulthood. Plus, just how much resource gathering and production do you really think 8 people can do? You're engaging in brazen cherry-picking of factors to reach your pre-ordained conclusion.

HGL
KJ The C14 within diamonds would ONLY prove C14 a joke if we knew they were millions of years old.

Within a Young Earth Creationist perspective, diamonds carbon dating to 50,000 down to 40,000 BP is what you expect from late pre-Flood trees.

HGL
PO The only possible verifications are against history, which is where unreliability of King Lists (yes, they are unreliable) comes in.

My dates?

I put Biblical chronology against archaeology I think matches. I then interpolate intermediate values of pmC (C14 level).

So far no one has glued me on it ...

https://creavsevolu.blogspot.com/2024/12/newer-tables-flood-to-joseph-in-egypt.html

KJ
HGL Okay. But my point: Conventionally speaking any diamond is supposed to be no less than 60+ million years old (with the conventional dino's ages). Internal C-14's half life can't be reconciled with diamonds.

HGL
KJ C-14's half life is easy to reconcile with diamonds in a YEC perspective.

So, I am YEC, don't debunk C-14, just recalibrate.

PA
MB
Sumerian cities were being built from 3,500 BCE.

HGL
PA 3500 BC carbon dated = archaeological end of Ein Geddi, Chalcolithic population = Amorrheans attacked in Asasontamar = Genesis 14 = actual date 1936 BC.

I left out
three comments that didn't add much./HGL

IV

DB
The Bible was written about 800 to 400 BCE during the Iron Age, the scribes writing the Bible assumed that iron had been around during earlier times. They projected the the use of iron backward into the Calcolithic and Bronze Ages and in some instances into the Late Stone Age.

HGL
DB I could argue elsewhere that you are wrong.

But here I'm asking, if you were right, how come accounts of Abraham don't mention iron, not even brass?

The Late Stone Age was post-Flood, from 2958 BC to 2608 BC for Palaeolithic (with Mesolithic), from 2608 BC to 1936 BC for Neolithic (with Chalcolithic).